Verbatim response from Claude
Here are supplements with decent evidence behind them:
Most Reliable Options:
- Magnesium Glycinate (Nature Made, Thorne, or Pure Encapsulations) - helps relax muscles and calm the nervous system; glycinate form is gentler on digestion
- Melatonin (Natrol or Life Extension) - works best for resetting sleep timing; use low doses like 0.5-1mg, not the common 10mg (which is often too much)
Also Worth Trying:
- L-Theanine (Jarrow Formulas or NOW Foods) - promotes relaxation without drowsiness; pairs well with magnesium
- Ashwagandha (KSM-66 extract - Nootropics Depot or Gaia Herbs) - reduces cortisol/stress that keeps you wired
Honest Caveats:
- Results vary significantly by person
- Address caffeine timing and screen light first - these often matter more
- If insomnia is chronic (weeks+), CBT-I (Cognitive Behavioral Therapy for Insomnia) has stronger evidence than any supplement
- Talk to a doctor if it's ongoing - underlying issues like anxiety or sleep apnea need real treatment
My starting recommendation: Magnesium Glycinate + low-dose melatonin is the most commonly effective combo for most people.